Who gets rewarded?

I just got called on the carpet for my Blue Oscar post, specifically this part:

And in the Best Original Screenplay category, we have a film (Bridesmaids) that has plot holes you can drive a truck through, but the male critics loved it. Why? Well, this isn’t the time to rant on about this, but it doesn’t take much digging to learn that many of the scenes that the male film critics liked best were, in fact, added by the film’s male producer & the film’s male director. So exactly who are we rewarding in this case…?

“Here’s the troubling part for me,” says my friend. “Are you implying that Bridesmaid’s women screenwriters [Kristen Wiig & Annie Mumolo] haven’t earned their ‘Best Original Screenplay’ nomination even though they are the WGA’s credited screenwriters?” Maybe you don’t like Bridesmaids, but it’s very complicated for women in Hollywood who are forced to make compromises in order to get their films made, & I don’t want to diminish their accomplishments in this weird environment.”

Here’s my response: No, I am not saying they don’t “deserve” it. You are totally right. The environment is definitely “complicated,” & that’s not my call.

What I am saying is that my guess is that the screenplay AM/KW actually wrote would never have passed thru the male filters without the male-critic-pleasing additions made by the male producer & the male director.

Sure, sometimes we all have to make compromises, but everyone should know that they’re compromises. And insofar as this particular film is “an exception” to my basic thesis (that films with a female sensibility rarely make it thru the male filters), it’s an exception that smells like “something is rotten in the state of Denmark.”

Two years ago, I did everything in my power to support Kathryn Bigelow because she deserved it (not only for The Hurt Locker but for her body of work).

But two years later, when NO WOMEN have been nominated for Best Director since, we do have to ask why the only woman who ever won a Best Director Oscar won it for a film that had no women in it.

And we do have to ask why none of the women who work with Meryl Streep ever get recognized for their contributions in an art form that is all about team effort.

If we do not question these stats, then we’re implicitly saying continued “compromises” are just fine & nothing needs changing 🙁

Click here to download Oscar Impact Chart as a pdf –> 2012OscarChart

Click HERE to read my review of Bridesmaids.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *